BOTH


*

*

The word both is a determinative sầu (in the terminology of CGEL). Determinatives are not per se singular or plural (except thesethose), but they select singular or plural nouns. When both appears without the head noun, as it does here, there is a fusion of functions & it becomes both the determiner & the head of the plural NP.. The verb then agrees with the plural NP.

Bạn đang xem: Both

*
(ignore the clumsy grey line above sầu Head)


*

It acts only lượt thích plural because, unlike each1 và none2, "both" refers lớn all of the elements & not to one of them.

Read these examples from the OALD:

Both of us were tired. - and not - **Both of us was tired.*Both of them were French - and not - **Both of them was French*.

(1) - Each is usually singular: "each of us knows about you".(2) - None can be both singular or plural: "none of us is/are going home.

Xem thêm: Recover My Files Full Crack Sinhvienit, Recover My Files 5

" (the singular khung is considered formal in BrE).

Note: for more accurate explanations, visit the liên kết, otherwise if I add too much info, this answer gets off topic.


*

*

Both is definitely plural.

Both me and my brother are doing our best at school

Here"s an explanation on using both. Although this explanation is irrelevant lớn the OP"s question, none of the examples there uses both as singular.

And here it is stated explicitly.


Highly active sầu question. Earn 10 reputation in order lớn answer this question. The reputation requirement helps protect this question from spam and non-answer activity.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged grammatical-number verb-agreement determiners quantifiers or ask your own question.


Use of “both” (“singular” vs “plural”, “nominative” vs “oblique”)
site thiết kế / hình ảnh © 2021 Staông xã Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. rev2021.6.8.39453


Your privacy

By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device và discchiến bại information in accordance with our Cookie Policy.